审稿速度:1.0 经验分享:已投被拒。供大家参考。
we thank you for your submission to cjcatal. ~~ we usually rejected those which do not carry due significance and novelty. i regret that i must decline the manuscript because of the insignificant novelty.
perhaps you don’t know that our journal has undertaken significant reformation since 2016. the journal has set a high standard (currently ~15% acceptance rate) and my understanding is that we only accept manuscript that is comparable to those published in journal of catalysis.
上一区了?
153
审稿速度:1.0
经验分享:我想问下 awaiting reviers scores 是什么意思,从投到现在一直是这个状态,已经10多天了。
119
审稿速度:1.0
经验分享:已投被拒。供大家参考。
we thank you for your submission to cjcatal. ~~ we usually rejected those which do not carry due significance and novelty. i regret that i must decline the manuscript because of the insignificant novelty.
perhaps you don’t know that our journal has undertaken significant reformation since 2016. the journal has set a high standard (currently ~15% acceptance rate) and my understanding is that we only accept manuscript that is comparable to those published in journal of catalysis.
50
速度超快,审稿人很负责,3个审稿人前后给我提了20多个问题,我都很认真回答了。感谢编辑和审稿人的意见,对我文章有实质性的帮助。
2019.06.11 submited
2019.06.13 under review
2019.07.01 major revision
2019.07.15 resubmited
2019.07.16 accepted
41
啊,很快吗?一篇已经从投稿到现在7个月多了还没有结果,不要拖了半年多再拒啊···郝哥哥 2016-11-01 发表::
接收率:约95% 审稿时间:约1个月 审稿很快!编辑部非常奇葩,所有数据要origin原始文件,图文摘要要可编辑文件,真是醉了,非常折腾人,非常麻烦!改了3次接收,接收又让改了3-4次,完全不知变通,以后决不再投
郝哥哥 2016-11-01 发表:: 接收率:约95% 审稿时间:约1个月 审稿很快!编辑部非常奇葩,所有数据要origin原始文件,图文摘要要可编辑文件,真是醉了,非常折腾人,非常麻烦!改了3次接收,接收又让改了3-4次,完全不知变通,以后决不再投
191
审稿速度:1.0 | 投稿命中率:95.0
经验分享:审稿很快!编辑部非常奇葩,所有数据要origin原始文件,图文摘要要可编辑文件,真是醉了,非常折腾人,非常麻烦!改了3次接收,接收又让改了3-4次,完全不知变通,以后决不再投
374
8月5号投稿,8月17号返回大修,两个审稿人,一个智商说语法有问题,另一个提了6个意见,有两个问题不太好回答,要求20天内返回,8月26号返回,过了两天直接接收,速度挺快的,还不错。
48
还算比较容易的吧,11-07投稿,11-25初审意见,12-20投修改稿,当天接收,耗时1个半月,审稿意见比较中肯,对像我这样刚接触科研的新手还不错
32