请问大家一般是几个审稿人呀?一定要3个审稿人的意见编辑才会做决定吗?我在research square上看到3月份邀请了5个审稿人,2个同意并审完了(1个3月底,1个4月初)但是现在5月份了状态还在under review,这里也没有显示review3 agree的信息。 Review #2 received Review #1 received Reviewer #2 agreed Reviewer #1 agreed 5 reviewer(s) invited Invitations sent on 13 Mar, 2024
we cannot accept the manuscript for publication, but would be interested in considering a revised version that addresses these serious concerns.这一意思是大修吗
请问大家一般是几个审稿人呀?一定要3个审稿人的意见编辑才会做决定吗?我在research square上看到3月份邀请了5个审稿人,2个同意并审完了(1个3月底,1个4月初)但是现在5月份了状态还在under review,这里也没有显示review3 agree的信息。
Review #2 received
Review #1 received
Reviewer #2 agreed
Reviewer #1 agreed
5 reviewer(s) invited
Invitations sent on 13 Mar, 2024
69
审稿速度:6.0 | 投稿命中率:25.0
经验分享:第二轮
Waiting for Revision 6th Sep 22
Decision Made 6th Sep 22
Editor Review Started 14th Jul 22
Initial Manuscript Review Started 13th Jul 22
Editor Assigned 13th Jul 22
Submission 11th Jul 22
第一轮
Revision Received 11th Jul 22
Waiting for Revision 26th May 22
Decision Made 25th May 22
Editor Review Started 7th Apr 22
Initial Manuscript Review Started 28th Mar 22
Editor Assigned 25th Mar 22
Submission 23rd Mar 22
84
we cannot accept the manuscript for publication, but would be interested in considering a revised version that addresses these serious concerns.这一意思是大修吗
19
偏重的研究方向:基因组学
经验分享:6月1日提交,submission状态,希望好运!!!
1
4.7提交,今天还是Submission,更新接好运
17
等的心急,太慢了
3
偏重的研究方向:眼科;角膜
经验分享:第一次尝试。
更新攒人品拉!
Initial Manuscript Review Started 26th Mar 24
Editor Assigned 25th Mar 24
Submission 20th Mar 24
希望可以顺利
18
Editor assigned已经持续5天了……
29
目前的进度:
Initial Manuscript Review Started 30th Apr 24
Editor Assigned 25th Apr 24
Submission 17th Apr 24
还是不太搞得懂这个杂志的外审是哪个阶段啊?这个initial review算吗?
8
审稿速度:24.0 | 投稿命中率:25.0
偏重的研究方向:昆虫共生菌
经验分享:Initial Manuscript Review Started 14th May 24
Editor Assigned 8th May 24
Submission 26th Apr 24
马上一个月了,请问intital manuscript review started持续十天是不是要悲剧了
4