submitted to journal: 2019.11.11
with editor: 2019.11.12
under review: 2019.11.13
under review: 2019.11.21
under editor evaluation: 2019. 12.11
revise(recommendation-from reviews and editor)要求一个月: 2019.12.19
revision submitted to journal: 2020.1.13
with editor: 2020.1.14
under review: 2020.1.14
accept pending journal confirmation: 2020.1.22 (ecm和ecmx选一个确认,后者开源收费,选的ecm,只替换cover letter,别的文件不能修改替换)
revision submitted to journal: 2020.1.25 (庚子初一)
with editor: 2020.1.27
completed-accept: 2020.1.27
审稿速度:2.0 经验分享:submitted to journal: 2019.10.30
with editor: 2019.10.31
under review: 2019.10.31
revise : 2019.12.06
revision submitted to journal: 2019.12.17
under review:2019.12.19
article accepted for publication: 20 jan 2020
submitted to journal: 2019.10.30
with editor: 2019.10.31
under review: 2019.10.31
revise : 2019.12.06
revision submitted to journal: 2019.12.17
under review:2019.12.19
审稿速度:1.0 经验分享:期刊处理稿件速度很快,审稿意见质量也很高。祝愿ecm越办越好!
submitted to journal: 09.27
with editor: 09.28
under review: 09.30
under review: 10.08
under editor evaluation: 10.21
revise: 10.30 (recommendation-from reviewers and editor)
revision submitted to journal: 11.12
with editor: 11.13
under review: 11.16
required reviews completed: 11.18
accept: 11.19
该期刊为能源领域顶级期刊,期刊的论文质量确实高。编辑人也好。
97
2019-9-27 投稿
2019-11-1 拒稿
四个审稿人,前三个都还可以,最后一个审稿人也提出不少意见,但指出创新不足,主编最终拒稿。这个刊的要求确实高。
76
submitted to journal: 2019.11.11
with editor: 2019.11.12
under review: 2019.11.13
under review: 2019.11.21
under editor evaluation: 2019. 12.11
revise(recommendation-from reviews and editor)要求一个月: 2019.12.19
revision submitted to journal: 2020.1.13
with editor: 2020.1.14
under review: 2020.1.14
accept pending journal confirmation: 2020.1.22 (ecm和ecmx选一个确认,后者开源收费,选的ecm,只替换cover letter,别的文件不能修改替换)
revision submitted to journal: 2020.1.25 (庚子初一)
with editor: 2020.1.27
completed-accept: 2020.1.27
89
审稿速度:2.0
经验分享:submitted to journal: 2019.10.30
with editor: 2019.10.31
under review: 2019.10.31
revise : 2019.12.06
revision submitted to journal: 2019.12.17
under review:2019.12.19
article accepted for publication: 20 jan 2020
62
submitted to journal: 2019.10.30
with editor: 2019.10.31
under review: 2019.10.31
revise : 2019.12.06
revision submitted to journal: 2019.12.17
under review:2019.12.19
77
2019.9.1 投稿
2019.10.23 返回修改意见;两个小修,一个大修,共12条修改意见
2019.11.27 提交修改稿
2020.1.2 接收
67
11/28 投稿
11/29 送审
12/07 送审时间变化、状态未变
12/16 审稿完成
12/17 拒(两修一拒,拒稿意见只有一句话:本研究缺乏科学价值)
总的来说,尽管结果不如我意,但这是一次比较愉快的投稿过程,因为我觉得编辑和审稿人都十分负责,两个返修的意见也都十分中肯,对论文的提升很有帮助。
准备换个期刊投,希望ecm越来越好!
71
审稿速度:1.0
经验分享:期刊处理稿件速度很快,审稿意见质量也很高。祝愿ecm越办越好!
submitted to journal: 09.27
with editor: 09.28
under review: 09.30
under review: 10.08
under editor evaluation: 10.21
revise: 10.30 (recommendation-from reviewers and editor)
revision submitted to journal: 11.12
with editor: 11.13
under review: 11.16
required reviews completed: 11.18
accept: 11.19
53
8.11投稿
10.16返回第一次修改 modify-general changes
11.21 revise-specific changes
11.23 再次提交
11.24 接收
我很喜欢这个期刊,以后的文章会首投ecm
55
7.24投稿,9.28接收,中间经历一次 modify-general changes
最喜欢的就是这个期刊的效率,在编辑手上绝对不会耽误时间,投稿后要的话一天就审稿了,不要的话立刻就拒稿,以后写的文章都会优先投ecm.
64