审稿速度:2.0 经验分享:感觉是非常专业的一个期刊,毕竟是top。一个半月就给了修改意见,两位审稿人,一位拒稿,一位大修,虽然最后给了拒稿的决定,但给的意见十分专业,对论文的后期修改有很大帮助。分享下时间节点,供大家参考:
submitted 2020.01.11
with editor 2020.01.18
under review 2020.01.24;2020.01.27;2020.01.30;2020.02.03;2020.02.06;2020.02.10 (日期更新多次)
decision and reject 2020.02.27
第14楼续一!
may 08,2019 submitted
……
nov 04, 2019 reconsidered after major revision (new ms)
jan 08, 2020 revision submitted to journal
jan 09, 2020 with editor
jan 14, 2020 under review
jan 16, 2020 under review
jan 18, 2020 under review
jan 24, 2020 under review
feb 04, 2020 required reviews completed
feb 04, 2020 under review
feb 10, 2020 required reviews completed
feb 13, 2020 acceptable after moderate revision (revised ms)
feb 19, 2020 revision submitted to journal
feb 20, 2020 with editor
2019.9.17 submitted to journal
2019.9.19 with editor第三天就到编辑手里了,还挺快
2019.9.23 under review隔了一个周末,找到了第一个审稿人?
2019.9.26 under review找到了另一个审稿人?
2019.10.30 under review日期再次变更,但状态未变,之前的审稿人意见相左?
2019.11.02 under review日期再次变更,啥情况?
2019.11.08 under review一大早8点50日期再次变更,啥情况?
2019.11.25 under review日期再次变更,找不到审稿人?
2019.11.28 under review日期又变更了,找不到审稿人?
2019.11.30 under review只有更改的日期,没有更改的状态
2019.12.28 under editor evaluation终于收集了所有审稿人意见!静待结果
审稿速度:2.0 经验分享:接上一条
文章二
sep 07, 2019 submitted
sep 09, 2019 with editor
sep 11, 2019 under review
sep 16, 2019 under review
sep 17, 2019 under review
oct 02, 2019 under editor evaluation
oct 22, 2019 decision in process
oct 22, 2019 acceptable after moderate revision (new ms)
oct 28, 2019 revision submitted to journal
oct 29, 2019 with editor
oct 29, 2019 under review
nov 05, 2019 under review
nov 27, 2019 accept
dec 10, 2019 online
总的来说,效率主要还是取决于审稿人。。。。
文章一
may 08,2019 submitted
may 09,2019 with editor
may 12,2019 under review
may 20,2019 under review
may 23,2019 under review
oct 15, 2019 under review
oct 16, 2019 under review
oct 31, 2019 under editor evaluation
nov 04, 2019 decision in process
nov 04, 2019 reconsidered after major revision (new ms)
至今仍在大修
如何判断两种药物之间是协同作用还是相加作用?
53
如果文章发表了未提供ORCIDID如何添加?
60
审稿速度:1.0
经验分享:投了半个月,editor给了几个理由直接拒掉了,听说最近几个人都是没送直接拒了,遗憾
139
审稿速度:2.0
经验分享:感觉是非常专业的一个期刊,毕竟是top。一个半月就给了修改意见,两位审稿人,一位拒稿,一位大修,虽然最后给了拒稿的决定,但给的意见十分专业,对论文的后期修改有很大帮助。分享下时间节点,供大家参考:
submitted 2020.01.11
with editor 2020.01.18
under review 2020.01.24;2020.01.27;2020.01.30;2020.02.03;2020.02.06;2020.02.10 (日期更新多次)
decision and reject 2020.02.27
115
续第17楼
feb 19, 2020 revision submitted to journal
feb 20, 2020 with editor
feb 21, 2020 accept
喜大普奔
137
第14楼续一!
may 08,2019 submitted
……
nov 04, 2019 reconsidered after major revision (new ms)
jan 08, 2020 revision submitted to journal
jan 09, 2020 with editor
jan 14, 2020 under review
jan 16, 2020 under review
jan 18, 2020 under review
jan 24, 2020 under review
feb 04, 2020 required reviews completed
feb 04, 2020 under review
feb 10, 2020 required reviews completed
feb 13, 2020 acceptable after moderate revision (revised ms)
feb 19, 2020 revision submitted to journal
feb 20, 2020 with editor
147
2019.9.17 submitted to journal
2019.9.19 with editor第三天就到编辑手里了,还挺快
2019.9.23 under review隔了一个周末,找到了第一个审稿人?
2019.9.26 under review找到了另一个审稿人?
2019.10.30 under review日期再次变更,但状态未变,之前的审稿人意见相左?
2019.11.02 under review日期再次变更,啥情况?
2019.11.08 under review一大早8点50日期再次变更,啥情况?
2019.11.25 under review日期再次变更,找不到审稿人?
2019.11.28 under review日期又变更了,找不到审稿人?
2019.11.30 under review只有更改的日期,没有更改的状态
2019.12.28 under editor evaluation终于收集了所有审稿人意见!静待结果
150
审稿速度:2.0
经验分享:接上一条
文章二
sep 07, 2019 submitted
sep 09, 2019 with editor
sep 11, 2019 under review
sep 16, 2019 under review
sep 17, 2019 under review
oct 02, 2019 under editor evaluation
oct 22, 2019 decision in process
oct 22, 2019 acceptable after moderate revision (new ms)
oct 28, 2019 revision submitted to journal
oct 29, 2019 with editor
oct 29, 2019 under review
nov 05, 2019 under review
nov 27, 2019 accept
dec 10, 2019 online
总的来说,效率主要还是取决于审稿人。。。。
126
文章一
may 08,2019 submitted
may 09,2019 with editor
may 12,2019 under review
may 20,2019 under review
may 23,2019 under review
oct 15, 2019 under review
oct 16, 2019 under review
oct 31, 2019 under editor evaluation
nov 04, 2019 decision in process
nov 04, 2019 reconsidered after major revision (new ms)
至今仍在大修
129
审稿太慢了,从投稿到被拒超过了7个月,可能是自己有些浮躁,但是仍觉得与审稿超过6个月相比,有些期刊送审前编辑把把关后直接拒稿更容易接受。
133